Moms Talk: Schools Ban Charlie Brown, Santa and Poinsettias

First, schools banned Halloween. Now a class outing to see a church performance of "A Charlie Brown Christmas" could be nixed as well. Have schools taken things too far when it comes to 'anti-Christmas' activities?

RANCHO SANTA MARGARITA, CA -- “A Charlie Brown Christmas” has been a holiday TV classic for years. So when students at Terry Elementary School in Little Rock, Ark., were invited on a class field trip to see a performance of the show this December, they were excited. But their excitement was quickly quenched when a parent complained; an atheist group got wind of the outing and called it a “violation of religious freedom” because it contains some religious content and will be performed at a church.

The school sent a letter home to the parents detailing the field trip and letting them know that it did, indeed, contain a small amount of religious content but that any child who wished not to go could be exempt from attending. The outing also included a food drive for area food pantries, which parents hope students will not miss out on if the outing is cancelled.

Schools around the nation have dealt with similar anti-Christmas sentiments. In Alabama, a group of 5- to 7- year -olds were asked not to sing “Silent Night” in their Christmas program because it was considered “unconstitutional.” The school overrode the complaint and students will be allowed to perform as planned. But in Davis, Cal., students at Emerson Junior High encountered a different outcome when the play they planned to perform, Charles Dickens’ “ A Christmas Carol,” was banned because of—you guessed it—the word “Christmas.”

The list goes on. In Stockton, the school district warned teachers not to put up any poinsettias, Christmas trees or other decorations that would be considered festive, just to make sure they did not offend anyone. And in Fort Worth, Texas, Santa was banned from classrooms because his visit was considered “endorsing religious activity.” The ban was later overturned and the schools agreed Santa could come to the schools but not enter the classrooms.

Contrast these times with the 1950s, when many kids performed in nativity plays at school, complete with Mary, Joseph and baby Jesus in the manger. Now, in places like Santa Monica, the mere sight of a nativity scene on public property is reason for outcry. In an age of “over-political correctness” have schools and cities taken things too far and taken the fun and meaning out of a holiday that’s been celebrated worldwide for years and years?

“We still talk about Kwanza, Hanukkah, Ramadan and the pagan celebration of winter solstice,” one blogger mom wrote. “I have no problem with exposing my children to those cultural holidays, but in fairness, shouldn’t we be able to discuss the origins of Christmas as well?”

Surprisingly, a Rasmussen Reports national television survey showed that 68 percent of most Americans still preferred the traditional greeting, “Merry Christmas” during the season. Yet most store employees and school teachers have been required to now use the less offensive “Happy Holidays” approach. A Christmas break is no longer called such at most schools; it is referred to as a holiday or winter break, merely due to the religious implications of the word. So are we really so offended after all?

I believe in God and celebrate Christmas with my family, yet I respect others’ views as well. However, I have yet to meet one person in my entire life who was offended by a poinsettia, a nativity scene, a Christmas cookie or—Heaven forbid—Santa Claus himself! For some reason, I can’t picture a 6-year-old child growing horrified upon seeing a wreath on his teacher’s door.  It seems a shame that we’ve taken not just the “Christmas” but the “Merry” out of so much of this special holiday season because of a few Grinches who insist on spoiling the fun for the kids.

Interestingly, no one seemed too “offended” when Black Friday shopping this year, as they piled their carts high with bargain brand named clothes, electronics and must-have toys. And no one yet has complained about the fact that Christmas is a Federal Holiday for all employees. Perhaps if we were being truly politically correct we should re-open the post office and send kids to school on December 25.

I’m being facetious, of course.

Parents, what do you think? Do you think schools should celebrate Christmas in the classrooms? And what of the schools that have banned certain plays, songs, decorations and activities? Do you think they’ve taken things too far, or do you think they’ve done the right thing?

We want to hear from you!

Anton October 28, 2013 at 03:19 PM
At least the school did not let one over reacting parent ruin the whole trip for the rest of the class. This is how it should be, give them the option NOT to attend then that parent will have to explain to his kids why they cannot go on this trip with the rest of their class.
Anton October 28, 2013 at 03:30 PM
We have a similar controversy here in Tennessee, a school in central TN. took a class to a Synagogue, a Buddhist temple and a Mosque, they kids got to meditate at the Buddhist temple and pray at the Mosque and each student was given a copy of the koran to take home. One student named Jessica refused to pray of take a koran and they threatened her with a bad grade, the school board backed down when it hit the news. I can only imagine if the school had taken the class to a Catholic church and they were given a wafer and some wine or grape juice, OMG the media would have had a field day with this along with the ACLU. It's okay to ignore and bash Christianity but you cannot do so with non Christian religions, its insensitive if you don't learn about Islam and the Muslim religion but okay if you trounce or bad mouth the Christian religion.
Dross Cool October 28, 2013 at 05:38 PM
met00 October 28, 2013 at 07:26 PM
Actually Tony, I would have no problem with a course in comparative mythology that looked at current mythology and went from one to the other (without the whole forced prayer crap). I think it is important to know all the different current myths.
met00 October 29, 2013 at 12:42 AM
Alas poor Dross, when the rapture never comes you will be left feeling foolish.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »